When your leadership team says “That wouldn’t work here,” how do you know? Sometimes that judgement is grounded in experience. But sometimes, it reflects an assumption that has been repeated long enough to become accepted wisdom.
I've been thinking about that distinction during my interviews for The Field Guide for Managing Partners. Across more than 30 conversations, one question has stood out: Should a managing partner continue to practice law? Historically, managing partners did both. They led their firms while continuing to serve clients and maintain books of business. It was simply how the job was done.
Over time, some firms departed from that model. Their managing partners became full-time leaders, and the firms haven't looked back. Those leaders tell me they can't imagine effectively managing the demands of a modern law firm while simultaneously maintaining a practice.
Others, including leaders of some of the country's largest firms, continue to practice. Their reasoning is that a managing partner needs a book of business to maintain credibility and influence among fellow partners. That's the assumption I keep coming back to.
If a managing partner cultivates strong relationships, earns colleagues' trust, and demonstrates sound judgment, couldn't that leader command influence without a book of business? Could the time devoted to clients instead be invested in becoming a more effective leader?
The firms that have adopted full-time leadership have experience to inform their position. Their experience doesn't establish what will work in every firm, but it does give us reason to question the idea that a book of business is a prerequisite for credibility. For a firm that has never tried another approach, how much of that conviction comes from evidence and how much comes from precedent?
This is where precedent can become a liability: when we treat what we've always done as proof of what we must keep doing.
Law is a profession built on precedent. Looking to the past for guidance is deeply familiar, and looking to peer firms for validation can feel reassuring. But inherited management practices can also constrain innovation, particularly when change demands that leaders consider approaches for which there is no established playbook. If we wait for an alternative to become conventional before considering it, we may miss the opportunity it presents.
The question isn't whether tradition is good or bad; it's whether we're sufficiently curious about the alternatives and willing to examine the assumptions behind our own decisions.
A question for your next leadership meeting:
Think of a peer firm that's made a strategic move you wouldn't have considered for your own firm. What do you think they're betting on? What would have to be true for that bet to pay off, and what evidence might change your mind?
There’s value in asking these questions within your own leadership team, and in hearing how other managing partners are navigating similar decisions at their firms. Our Managing Partners Roundtable (MPR) brings firm leaders together to exchange perspectives, challenge assumptions, and learn from one another.